Lifting pages off the discs
Creator CollectiveAd library: what works, and what doesn't

Real Paper State ads from our creators (names kept private), with what we think made them work, or not. Watch a few before you film: tap a video to play. Back to the Creator hub · Open briefs

What's working

Top performer

Creator A · "Build my planner"

58 SALES FROM ONE VIDEO

  • Face to camera from the very first second.
  • Real excitement opening her planner, then building it as she talks.
  • Natural, at home, unpolished: like a friend showing you.
Strong performer

Creator B · Writing in bed

52 SALES

  • Real writing, in a real, cosy setting.
  • You see the planner being used, not described.
  • Proof that real use sells. Imagine it with a face-to-camera hook in the first 3 seconds.
Worked

Creator E · Talking to camera

7 SALES · STRONG START, FADED AFTER ~6 WEEKS

  • Face to camera, talking honestly about her life.
  • Four sales in its first fortnight, then it wore out, as every ad eventually does. That's why fresh videos matter.
Performed well

Creator C · On the sofa

FACE TO CAMERA, AT HOME

  • Relaxed and natural, planner in hand.
  • Feels like a chat with a friend on the couch.
New · early signs good

Creator D · The unboxing

RUNNING NOW

  • Face to camera with a real unboxing moment.
  • Genuine reactions, at home.

What hasn't worked

Didn't land

Creator A again · Hands only

2 SALES (VS 58 FOR HER FACE-TO-CAMERA VIDEO)

  • Same creator, same planner, but no face and no hook at the start.
  • The opening made all the difference.
Didn't land

Creator F · Cart screen recording

UNDERPERFORMED

  • A screen, not a person: nothing to connect with.
  • (The offer shown is old and no longer running.)
The biggest lesson here: Creator A made both our best video (58 sales) and one of our weakest (2 sales). Same person, same planner. The difference was starting face to camera with a real moment, instead of hands and no hook.
The pattern so far: you, face to camera, holding the planner, in your real life, ending with one clear next step. See the do's and don'ts for the details.